October 31, 2005

P0wned by Sony

sony_boycott.jpg

I'm a pretty loyal Sony customer and have been for some time. I own several Sony radios and a fairly expensive Sony digital camera. When I recently helped my girlfriend select a TV, I recommended a Sony. If somebody wants to know what DVD player to buy, I'll tell them to get a Sony. Were you to ask me for a good name for your newborn male child, I would suggest that you name him Sony McSonycutty, even if your surname were not McSonycutty.

Until now.

Here's the deal. When the writers of malicious software (viruses, trojans, bots, etc.) want to hide their program on your computer — so that you can't see it in the file explorer, in the list of running programs, etc. — they use something called a rootkit. Rootkits modify your operating system so that it lies to you about what's on your PC. They are difficult to detect, and difficult to remove.

It now appears that certain CDs sold by Sony Music use a rootkit to hide the Digital Rights Management (DRM) software they install to prevent you from doing perfectly legitimate things like transferring your music to your iPod.

Look at the mess this guy had to go through to a) realize he had been tricked into putting a rootkit on his PC and b) remove it.

I'm the kind of person who feels bad about copying CDs. If somebody asks me to burn them an album, I'll sometimes buy the CD as a gift so the artist can make some money (i.e., a small fraction of the retail price). And now we see how Sony rewards their customers, people who chose to purchase music rather than copy it from the net. Next time, perhaps, I'll find another way to obtain the album, and mail the artist a check, or a Denny's gift certificate, or something, instead.

Posted by cradle at October 31, 2005 6:37 PM
Comments

Bastards. Are macs immune?

Posted by: Brooke at October 31, 2005 7:51 PM

Also, the link to the guy is broken.

Posted by: Brooke at October 31, 2005 7:52 PM

wow. Thanks for the link. Going to pass it on . . .

Posted by: doug at October 31, 2005 9:31 PM

I wish you had told me about this relationship you had with sony sooner, so I could have explained to you that obviously were obviously turning to sony to fill a deep void in your soul left by years of physical and sexual abuse.

Because I bought this DVD player from them, sometime before DVD players were inexpensive. So it cost like five times what it should have. And it stopped working exactly one week after its warantee expired.

Posted by: Anonymous at October 31, 2005 9:48 PM

The "this guy" link seems to be working again. Ahhh, it showed up on Slashdot. They seem to have recovered. The rootkit he describes is Windows specific; I'm not sure what goodies they've added for OS X.

DVD person: is that you, Cliff? It's you, right?

Posted by: David at October 31, 2005 11:31 PM

Yeah, it's a really bad scene, that DRM. There was a protest in NYC: http://flickr.com/photos/fcb/sets/1229792/

via boingboing, which has been talking about the damages of DMR for a while and people are getting riled up about it. Glad you're on the trolley too! The ironic thing is that DRM doesn't even help artists. Most of them these days would rather have their work floating around on ipods--it's like an advertisement. Even your example of the burned CD. This type of digital saturation usually encourages even more legit purchases.

Posted by: shannon at November 1, 2005 7:57 AM

People are already working around DMR:
http://blog.commonbits.org/2005/10/commonmedia_lau.html

it's a good thing.

Posted by: shannon at November 2, 2005 11:01 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?




Verification (needed to reduce spam):